All research

Biomedical devices & simulation · 2018–2019

Low-cost ECMO cannulation simulator for clinical training

A mannequin-based training system with simulated circulation, ultrasound-compatible access pads and sensors for cannulation errors.

Qatar University and Hamad Medical Corporation · Qatar National Research Fund UREP22-003-2-001

Block diagram of the ECMO training system and cannulation trainer. The trainer contains cannulation pads, arterial and venous circuits, a heart model, pulsatile and laminar flow pumps, tanks of blood-like liquid and a microprocessor.
Figure 1 from Khurshid et al. (2018). The ECMO training eco-system (a) and proposed cannulation trainer (b).View full-size figureSource articleCC BY-NC-ND 4.0

Approach

Can a lower-cost simulator recreate the anatomy, circulation and errors that matter during ECMO cannulation training?

ECMO cannulation is a high-risk procedure, and many training simulators are expensive or represent only part of the circulation. Working with ECMO clinicians, the project developed a mannequin-based trainer with arterial and venous flow, ultrasound-compatible access pads and sensors that respond to procedural errors.

  1. Define clinical training needs
  2. Build pads and circulation loops
  3. Add sensors and test errors

Designing the trainer around clinical needs

The Egyptian Journal of Critical Care Medicine · 2018

ECMO teams must monitor many variables and respond quickly to emergencies, so hands-on training is essential. With ECMO clinicians at Hamad Medical Corporation, the team defined a lower-cost cannulation trainer to work alongside a separate ECMO machine simulator.

The design used a closed circulation system with arterial and venous networks, thermochromic blood-like fluid and silicone cannulation pads. It was planned to support guidewire insertion, vessel dilation, cannula placement and ultrasound-guided positioning, with sensors for procedural emergencies.

Connected simulator subsystems
2
ECMO configurations planned
3
Cannulation approaches planned
3
Training capabilities planned by Khurshid et al. (2018).
Design target
ECMO configurationsVA, VV and VV-A
Cannulation approachesFemoro-femoral, femoro-jugular and dual-lumen jugular
CirculationPulsatile arterial flow and laminar venous flow
Emergency scenariosFlow pressure changes and cannula migration alarms

Building the first cannulation prototype

IEEE SCOReD · 2019

The prototype connected venous and arterial loops inside a mannequin. It included incorrect paths, such as a simulated renal vein, and ultrasound-compatible access pads based on femoral anatomy, with the artery above the larger vein and a superficial artery as a possible wrong route.

Pads were cast in designed moulds from silicone rubber, and a 3D-printed Y-connector allowed two large cannulas to meet in the venous path. A force-sensing resistor detected guidewire entry into the renal vein and triggered an LED. The team then integrated the subsystems into the mannequin and tested cannula insertion through the femoral arterial pad.

Interconnected circulation loops
2
Pad solidification time
2 hours
Sensor screw angle in the Y-connector
60°
Prototype features described by Mahmoud et al. (2019), IEEE SCOReD.
Implementation
Arterial and venous flowPulsatile arterial loop and laminar venous loop
Access trainingUltrasound-compatible, anatomically arranged silicone pads
Wrong-path trainingSimulated renal vein and superficial artery
Bleeding eventFlow drop in the closed loop alerts the instructor
Guidewire errorForce-sensing resistor detects renal vein entry
Diagram of a human torso with red arterial and blue venous circuits, femoral access pads, renal and hepatic veins, sensors, pumps, tanks and a microcontroller.
Figure 1 from Mahmoud et al. (2019), IEEE SCOReD. Block diagram of the proposed cannulation simulator.View full-size figureSource article© 2019 IEEE · author reuse
Three views of the cannulation pad mould with red and blue channels representing the artery and vein.
Figure 3 from Mahmoud et al. (2019), IEEE SCOReD. Cannulation pad mould design from different angles.View full-size figureSource article© 2019 IEEE · author reuse
A 3D model of the Y-connector beside the 3D-printed connector.
Figure 5 from Mahmoud et al. (2019), IEEE SCOReD. Y-connector 3D model (left) and 3D-printed part (right).View full-size figureSource article© 2019 IEEE · author reuse
Two photographs of the training mannequin, showing the implemented system and a cannula inserted through the left femoral pad.
Figure 8 from Mahmoud et al. (2019), IEEE SCOReD. Mannequin with the implemented system (a) and cannula inserted in the left femoral pad (b).View full-size figureSource article© 2019 IEEE · author reuse

Improving anatomy, circulation and error detection

Qatar Medical Journal · 2019

The improved simulator added a closed loop linking jugular and femoral access points, with a pump and tank to regulate flow. A pump created pulsatile arterial flow, while venous flow remained laminar. The inferior vena cava junction allowed two cannulas to pass and included an alternative path representing the renal vein.

Testing focused on recalibrating the force sensor in liquid and adjusting pulsatile flow for realistic pressure. With jugular and femoral access, the simulator could support training for veno-arterial and veno-venous ECMO.

Access regions: jugular and femoral
2
ECMO training modes supported
VA and VV
Main prototype limitations identified
3
Testing focus and limitations reported by Mahmoud et al. (2019), Qatar Medical Journal.
Outcome
Force sensorRecalibrated in the presence of liquid
Pulsatile flowOptimised for pressure realism
Current limitationsTube flexibility, sensor measurement limits and rigid 3D-printing material
Composite figure showing the pad mould, printed mould with silicone, finished access pad, inferior vena cava connector parts, Y-connector, embedded system diagram and improved mannequin simulator.
Figure 1 from Mahmoud et al. (2019), Qatar Medical Journal. Fabricated parts, embedded system and improved prototype.View full-size figureSource articleCC BY 4.0

My contribution

I helped design, build and test the simulator and wrote the Arduino control code for the pump motor used to reproduce pulsatile flow. I also contributed to technical documentation and manuscript preparation, and attended hands-on ECMO training at Hamad General Hospital and Al-Wakra Hospital. The SCOReD presentation received the Best Paper Presentation Award for its presenting author, and the UREP project placed third in the 12th Annual UREP Competition in 2020.

Study scope

These papers describe simulator design and prototype testing. They do not report a formal study of trainee learning or clinical outcomes. Further testing by ECMO clinicians and improvements to tubing, sensing and printed materials were still needed.